Compare

Bare Knuckle Peacemaker vs Seymour Duncan Whole Lotta Humbucker (SH-18)

We found no spec differences between them worth calling out.

Specs side by side

differs marks specs where they part ways
SpecBare Knuckle PeacemakerSeymour Duncan Whole Lotta Humbucker (SH-18)
DC resistancediffers9.6k8.78k
Inductancediffers5.19 H (measured, 1 reading)5.31 H (compiled)
MagnetAlnico 5Alnico 5
CoilHum-cancellingHum-cancelling
Resonant peakdiffers—6.14 kHz (Seymour Duncan's own test load)
Bass (tone chart)differs6 / 10no chart
Mids (tone chart)differs8 / 10no chart
Treble (tone chart)differs6 / 10no chart
Slotbridge humbuckerbridge humbucker
Traitsvintage output, dark, mid-forwardvintage output

How close on each spec

100 means identical on that spec. The score weighs these, and counts anything we couldn't compare as a typical difference. How scoring works

Output
97
measured inductance
Magnet
100
both Alnico 5
Coil
100
same coil type

Not compared: brightness, mids, bass (a spec is missing for at least one of them).

Videos

Bare Knuckle Peacemaker

Seymour Duncan Whole Lotta Humbucker (SH-18)

What players and reviewers say

On the Bare Knuckle Peacemaker

“The low end is thick without getting soggy.”
Darth Phineas · Nov 19, 2025Darth Phineas ↗ (opens in a new tab)
“The highs stay sweet and round but still have enough bite to talk back when you dig in.”
Darth Phineas · Nov 19, 2025Darth Phineas ↗ (opens in a new tab)
Everything on the Bare Knuckle Peacemaker →

On the Seymour Duncan Whole Lotta Humbucker (SH-18)

“Tried a Whole Lotta Humbucker and that went too far the other way as I suppose I like hotter than vintage and it was too harsh in the midrange, too spiky.”
JarickL · 2016-11-19Seymour Duncan forum ↗ (opens in a new tab)
“I have my Whole Lotta Neck set fairly close to the strings (2/32 ths for both the treble and bass side) I have not adjusted the polepieces.”
Mr. B · 2013-09-04Seymour Duncan forum ↗ (opens in a new tab)
Everything on the Seymour Duncan Whole Lotta Humbucker (SH-18) →

Full reviews