Compare

DiMarzio D Sonic vs Seymour Duncan Black Winter

Compared with the DiMarzio D Sonic, the Seymour Duncan Black Winter has lower output, more midrange and tighter low end.

Specs side by side

differs marks specs where they part ways
SpecDiMarzio D SonicSeymour Duncan Black Winter
DC resistancediffers11.96k13k
Inductancediffers6.27 H (measured, 1 reading)5.64 H (measured, 2 readings)
MagnetCeramicCeramic
CoilHum-cancellingHum-cancelling
Resonant peakdiffers—6.35 kHz (Seymour Duncan's own test load)
Bass (tone chart)differsEach maker grades its own chart, so read these within a brand6 / 105 / 10
Mids (tone chart)differsEach maker grades its own chart, so read these within a brand5.75 / 109 / 10
Treble (tone chart)differsEach maker grades its own chart, so read these within a brand4.5 / 107 / 10
Slotdiffershumbuckerneck humbucker
Traitsmoderate output, tight & aggressivemoderate output, mid-forward, tight & aggressive

How close on each spec

100 means identical on that spec. The score weighs these, and counts anything we couldn't compare as a typical difference. How scoring works

Output
85
measured inductance
Magnet
100
both Ceramic
Coil
100
same coil type
Brightness
90
each against its maker's average
Mids
24
each against its maker's average
Bass
57
each against its maker's average

Videos

DiMarzio D Sonic

DiMarzio D SONIC DP207 - Standard VS Reversed Position | Guitar Bridge Pickup Tone Comparison Demo
Mike Stamper · comparison

Seymour Duncan Black Winter

What players and reviewers say

On the DiMarzio D Sonic

“But, I just traded the D-Sonic (too thick and dark for me) in for a Steve's Special (hopefully a bit brighter and articulate)...”
pedalinbob · 2006-12-28Seymour Duncan forum ↗ (opens in a new tab)
“I wouldn't put the D Sonic in a baswood body cause basswood has tons of midrange and low end so your sound might turn to mud..”
Orange · 2007-04-05Seymour Duncan forum ↗ (opens in a new tab)
Everything on the DiMarzio D Sonic →

On the Seymour Duncan Black Winter

“It doesn't have as much of a dramatic low-end rolloff as the Black Winter, but it not a fat bassy pickup like the X2N.”
Rex Rocker · 2023-12-08Rig-Talk ↗ (opens in a new tab)
“The Black Winter and Distortion sound similar too, I hear the high end clarity on the Black Winter:.”
Dejoblue · 2013-10-11Seymour Duncan forum ↗ (opens in a new tab)
Everything on the Seymour Duncan Black Winter →

Full reviews

DiMarzio D Sonic

None collected yet.