Compare

DiMarzio Illuminator vs Seymour Duncan Black Winter

high confidence

Compared with the DiMarzio Illuminator, the Seymour Duncan Black Winter has a brighter top end and more midrange.

Specs side by side

differs marks specs where they part ways
SpecDiMarzio IlluminatorSeymour Duncan Black Winter
DC resistancediffers10.56k16.6k
Inductancediffers6.77 H (measured, 1 reading)6.98 H (measured, 2 readings)
MagnetCeramicCeramic
CoilHum-cancellingHum-cancelling
Resonant peakdiffers—6.68 kHz (Seymour Duncan's own test load)
Bass (tone chart)Each maker grades its own chart, so read these within a brand5 / 105 / 10
Mids (tone chart)differsEach maker grades its own chart, so read these within a brand6 / 109 / 10
Treble (tone chart)differsEach maker grades its own chart, so read these within a brand3.5 / 107 / 10
Slotbridge humbuckerbridge humbucker
Traitsmoderate output, dark, tight & aggressivemoderate output, mid-forward, tight & aggressive

How close on each spec

100 means identical on that spec. The score weighs these, and counts anything we couldn't compare as a typical difference. How scoring works

Output
96
measured inductance
Magnet
100
both Ceramic
Coil
100
same coil type
Brightness
59
each against its maker's average
Mids
31
each against its maker's average
Bass
74
each against its maker's average

Videos

DiMarzio Illuminator

Seymour Duncan Black Winter

What players and reviewers say

On the DiMarzio Illuminator

“In this guitar, Illuminator has a balanced EQ w/ slightly less highs.”
marytakesadrag · 2015-10-09Seymour Duncan forum ↗ (opens in a new tab)
“The lows are controlled and big… never muddy, loose or flabby… but not constricted, brittle or overly tight.”
Darth Phineas · May 31, 2023Darth Phineas ↗ (opens in a new tab)
Everything on the DiMarzio Illuminator →

On the Seymour Duncan Black Winter

“It doesn't have as much of a dramatic low-end rolloff as the Black Winter, but it not a fat bassy pickup like the X2N.”
Rex Rocker · 2023-12-08Rig-Talk ↗ (opens in a new tab)
“The Black Winter and Distortion sound similar too, I hear the high end clarity on the Black Winter:.”
Dejoblue · 2013-10-11Seymour Duncan forum ↗ (opens in a new tab)
Everything on the Seymour Duncan Black Winter →

Full reviews